_{If this email has been forwarded to you, sign up here}

The first failure - the original sin - of the NDIS wasn’t fraud. It wasn’t autism. It wasn’t participants asking for too much. It was politics.

Popular politics. Necessary politics, in many ways. But politics all the same.

At the scheme’s birth, politicians and advocates promised to end a shameful old system of rationed support and replace it with something bigger, fairer, demand-driven. The moral case was overwhelming. The design work was not.

Rick Morton, probably the journalist who reported on the NDIS more closely than anyone in Australia, has now written the bluntest version of this story. Gillard’s promise, he says, was political. It was also one she “couldn’t keep”. His central warning is colder: “disabled people will be the ones who are punished when poor planning meets political mongrel.”

This is what’s happening now.

With another take, designer Daniel Reeders goes to the design flaw eating away at the scheme’s foundations. The NDIS was never just a support system; it was a market experiment. Participants were given budgets and told to buy services from providers. But nobody properly specified what services or how muvh they should cost. Reeders calls this “the original sin of the NDIS scheme design - magical thinking about markets”.

The result was predictable. The old service ecosystem withered. Governments watched as costs rose, then rediscovered fiscal restraint once the political mood shifted and the bills mounted.

Now Mark Butler talks about restoring the scheme’s social licence. Chris Coombes’ LinkedIn video shows why that language has landed so badly in the sector. Coombes asks whether the NDIS really has lost its social licence.

He points to the political failure at the centre. The scheme was born from goodwill. It’s being repaired through fear.

People with Disability were promised support and care by people who didn’t, who couldn’t meet their commitments. Today they are paying the bill.

[continue reading on the abilityNEWS website]

Core disability and advocacy issues

NDIS reform must not entrench group homes
Summer Foundation says some of Minister Butler’s proposed NDIS changes are overdue, but warns that commissioning group homes and cutting social and community participation could reverse progress for people with high support needs. The organisation argues reform should be judged against the NDIS’s original promise of independence, inclusion and choice.
Summer Foundation

Soft organisational / newsroom content

PWDA explains what is known — and what is not
PWDA published a plain-language explainer for members on the latest NDIS changes, including access, framework planning, social and community participation, foundational supports, provider registration and payment systems. The update says many details remain unclear and notes concerns about whether replacement supports will be available when people need them.
People with Disability Australia

NDIS reform needed to restore sustainability and original purpose
Productivity Commission social policy commissioner Angela Jackson argues the NDIS needs continued reform to restore sustainability, service quality and the scheme’s original purpose. The piece supports stronger provider regulation, rebuilding supports outside the NDIS and addressing pressure created by mainstream service failure.
The Australian | Angela Jackson Paywall: Yes

New NDIS eligibility tool will be ‘relatively blind’ to diagnoses: Butler
The Age reports Mark Butler saying the proposed NDIS eligibility tool will focus on functional impairment rather than diagnosis, as the government tries to reset who receives support through the scheme. The story is directly relevant to concerns about autism, developmental delay and whether participants will be assessed fairly under the proposed model.
The Age

Mark Butler unveils NDIS overhaul to save $15 billion by 2030
The Canberra Times reports on Butler’s plan to cut annual NDIS growth to 5 per cent and save $15 billion by 2030. The public preview frames the overhaul as an attempt to secure the scheme’s future and prevent a budget blowout.
The Canberra Times Paywall: Yes

NDIS cuts: 160,000 to lose support under Butler’s brutal plan
The Daily Telegraph reports on fears among disabled Australians after Butler confirmed plans that could remove 160,000 people from the NDIS. Public preview material says the piece focuses on uncertainty about who will remain eligible, possible cuts to social and community participation, and concerns from participants worried about losing vital support.
Daily Telegraph Paywall: Yes

Fixing the NDIS won’t help the one in five Australians living with these challenges
WAtoday reports that NDIS reform will not resolve the broader lack of psychosocial and mental health supports for Australians who sit outside the scheme. Public preview material frames the issue as a gap affecting about one in five Australians and argues the NDIS reset leaves wider mental health support failures unresolved.
WAtoday

Uncertainty and fear as major NDIS overhaul leaves Logan providers and participants waiting
MyCity Logan reports local providers and participants are anxious about Butler’s proposed NDIS overhaul, including tighter eligibility rules, reassessments and the shift toward foundational supports. The story quotes a Loganholme provider staff member saying participants are “panicking” and fearful they may be removed or have funding cut.
MyCity Logan | Emma Knuckey

Mark Butler unveils NDIS overhaul, testing Anthony Albanese government
Jack Waterford’s Canberra Times column argues Butler’s NDIS overhaul will test the Albanese government politically as it tries to restrain scheme costs while preserving public and sector support. Public preview material identifies the piece as commentary on significant NDIS reforms and their implications for the government.
The Canberra Times | Jack Waterford Paywall: Yes

Concerns NDIS watchdog will be overwhelmed by reforms
Radio National Breakfast examined concerns that the NDIS Quality and Safeguards Commission could be overwhelmed by the government’s plan to register more NDIS providers. The segment featured Independent MP Rebekha Sharkie and focused on whether safeguards capacity can keep pace with the reforms.
ABC Listen, ABC Radio National Breakfast | Sally Sara
Time of publication: 6:45am Tuesday 28 April 2026

Half-baked promise to axe 160,000 from NDIS is not leadership material from Albanese government
The West Australian opinion piece by Jessica Page: criticises the Albanese Government’s plan to remove 160,000 people from the NDIS, framing it as poor leadership and an underdeveloped reform promise.
The West Australian | Jessica Page Paywall: Yes