Nathan Fitzgerald’s death was a freak accident. It was also football. The question is not whether anyone meant harm. It is whether Australian Rules is doing enough to stop deadly brain injury killing players, quickly or slowly.

Nathan Fitzgerald died playing football.

That’s a simple sentence. It is also the one the game is struggling to absorb.

The 27-year-old Melbourne teacher suffered fatal head injuries during a reserves match at Lalor Reserve in Melbourne’s north. His club believes he suffered three head knocks in quick succession: a head clash with a teammate, then from a knee or boot, and a final collision with a hard cricket pitch in the middle of the oval. (ABC News)

It is right to call this a ‘freak accident’. It was rare. It was sudden. There is no suggestion of malice. But that can’t be allowed to become a full stop.

Yes, a grass-covered, concrete cricket-pitch at the centre of the field base provided the devastating final collision that killed the player. (ABC News) But a bigger question remains about the game itself.

Australian Rules is not supposed to be a head-contact sport but the mechanics of football send bodies into the air, turning tackles into collisions. Players are driven backwards, sideways, and down. The rhythm of the game ensures the head is dangerously vulnerable.

That is why Fitzgerald’s death cannot be isolated from a growing brain-injury crisis.

Public reporting has not established a series of on-field Australian Rules injury and death from head injury. It has established something more uncomfortable: a growing list of former players dead with brain disease linked to repeated head trauma.

Four Corners reported last week that 33 Australian Rules footballers, including 19 professional or semi-professional players, have been diagnosed with CTE. (ABC Four Corners / ABC News)

This is not a freak accident. That is a pattern.

__________________________________________

[continue reading from abilityNEWS newsletter]

The AFL says player safety is its priority and it has changed rules. It has concussion protocols. It says it will limit physical contact in training from the 2027 pre-season. It points to education, medical advice and continuing research. (ABC News)

But this is not enough.

Four Corners did not argue simply that football has a concussion problem. The stronger case is that concussion is only the visible part of the danger.

Neuropathologist Michael Buckland said CTE is driven by repeated head impacts, many of which produce no obvious symptoms. Alan Pearce put the point even more sharply: the risk includes sub-concussive impacts — continual bumps, tackles, being thrown to the ground, getting up and playing on. (Four Corners transcript)

The problem is this is an inherent part of the game. The dangerous act is not always a reportable hit. Sometimes it is just football.

That is why the local oval matters. Fitzgerald was not an AFL star surrounded by cameras, club doctors and broadcast scrutiny. He was a local player in a reserves game. That is where the sport is most exposed. The simple assumption is that everyone knows the risk.

We don’t - and the AFL’s attitude to such a vital issue is to bury their heads in the sand and put hands to their ears.

Four Corners told the story of Nick Lowden, who died at 23 and was later diagnosed with CTE, the youngest known Australian Rules player with the disease. It also returned to Adam Hunter, the West Coast premiership player who died in 2025 and was posthumously diagnosed with CTE. Hunter’s family said he had suffered repeated head knocks and concussions across his football life. (Nick Lowden, ABC; Adam Hunter, ABC)

These are not identical cases. Fitzgerald’s death was acute. Lowden and Hunter sit in the longer CTE story. But they belong in the same public argument.

Football keeps treating head trauma as a series of sad exceptions. One bad landing. One accidental clash. One player with symptoms. One grieving family. One hard cricket pitch.

That is the wrong frame.

That’s why exposure is so vital. How often do the mechanics of the game expose the brain to force? How many of those forces are avoidable? What has to change before the next family is told it was nobody’s fault?

A sport can be loved and still be too dangerous. A death can be accidental and still reveal a system in dysfunction. A game can be part of community life and still need harder rules, safer grounds, fewer collisions, clearer warnings and fewer excuses.

The next response cannot just be black armbands.

It has to be change.

_______________________________________

Nathan Fitzgerald — died July 2026. Epping Football Netball Club player; suffered fatal head injuries after multiple impacts during a reserves match at Lalor Reserve. ABC News

Nick Lowden — died 2023; reported in Four Corners’ 2026 investigation. Semi-professional Australian Rules player; youngest known Australian Rules footballer diagnosed with CTE. ABC News

Adam Hunter — died 2025; CTE diagnosis reported before the 2026 Four Corners follow-up. West Coast premiership player; family said he suffered many head knocks and concussions. ABC News

Shane Tuck and Danny Frawley — earlier deaths central to the coronial and CTE debate. Both were found to have CTE after death; Four Corners noted coroners had recommended AFL partnership with brain banks. ABC News

Phoenix Spicer — Former AFL player for North Melbourne, died suddenly aged 23 on 3 January. Originally played for Darwin in the NTFL and later joined the VFL club Footscray for the past two seasons. The Nightly

Neale Daniher — Former AFL footballer, Australian of the Year and motor neurone disease campaigner died on 24 May. He was 65 years of age, and the ex-Essendon player attributed his medical condition to AFL. ABC News